DTC No 1 Pty Ltd & ors v David Norman Matthew & ors
[2009] NSWSC 1280
Summary updated 11 November 2026
Overview
DTC No 1 Pty Ltd & ors v David Norman Matthew & ors [2009] NSWSC 1280 is an ex tempore ruling on evidence given by Brereton J in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 13 October 2009, during the hearing. The plaintiffs tendered two e-mails marked "Without Prejudice", and the defendants objected on the basis of without prejudice privilege under s 131(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) [1]. Brereton J was satisfied, for the purpose of s 131(2)(g), that evidence already adduced was likely to mislead the Court unless the without prejudice communication was adduced to qualify it, and he admitted the e-mails as PX09 [5].
Facts
The plaintiffs were DTC No 1 Pty Ltd, Weriton Pty Ltd, Graham Keith Werry and Weriton Properties Pty Ltd, and the defendants were David Norman Matthew and Joy Elizabeth Matthew. The e-mails, dated 18 and 21 April 2008, were sent by Morton & Harris to Mr Werry, were each marked "Without Prejudice", and related to an attempt to implement an in principle compromise of a dispute about repayment of the preliminary finance [1]. On 2 May 2008 Mr Werry replied by a letter that was open on its face and referred to continuation of the joint venture agreement [2]. That letter was used in his cross-examination to suggest that he thought the plaintiffs would not be well served by pursuing the joint venture and in effect wanted to terminate it [2]. By a letter of 5 May 2008 the defendants' solicitors professed surprise that the plaintiff would wish to assert that the Joint Venture Agreement still had some operative effect [2]. On 8 May 2008 Mr Werry responded with a proposal to consider restructuring the joint venture, and that letter was also used in cross-examination to suggest that he did not wish to proceed with the joint venture [2]. In the meantime, by a letter of 7 May, Mr Werry had answered the 5 May letter, asserting that DTC considered the Joint Venture Agreement to be operative, but that letter emerged only in re-examination [3].
Procedural history
The ruling was made in the course of the hearing, when the plaintiffs tendered the e-mails during the re-examination of Mr Werry [1]. The reasons describe no earlier steps in the proceedings.
Issues
Held
Brereton J
Brereton J set out how Mr Werry's letters of 2 and 8 May 2008 had been used in cross-examination to suggest that he did not wish to continue the joint venture, and noted that his letter of 7 May, asserting that DTC considered the agreement operative, emerged only in re-examination [2]–[3]. He found that the tendered material showed Mr Matthew's solicitors submitting a proposed Deed of Termination of the Joint Venture to Mr Werry [4]. In his view the material, "at least potentially", revealed "a rather radically different view of events" from that which might appear or be inferred if it were not admitted [4]. He was satisfied, for the purpose of s 131(2)(g), that evidence adduced in the proceedings, or inferred from that evidence, was likely to mislead the Court unless evidence of the without prejudice communication was adduced to qualify it [5]. On that basis he admitted the material under objection as PX09 [5]. The reasons cite no earlier cases.
Orders. Brereton J admitted the e-mails under objection into evidence as PX09 [5]. The cover records the decision as "Evidence admitted". No other order is recorded.
Why it matters
Cited in 4 later casesSee every one in casewise